Quick answer: Buying motives are the real, often unspoken reasons a prospect wants what you sell. They are not the same as their stated needs, and they matter more than anything you know about your own product. Gitomer's Discover commandment puts it plainly: people buy for their reasons, not yours. Find theirs first.
Why your product knowledge is not the point
Most salespeople walk in ready to talk about what they sell. The mistake is thinking that is the sale. It is not. The sale lives in why the other person wants it, and that "why" is almost never what shows up on the surface.
I have built two companies without a sales team, which meant every one of those conversations came down to me and the prospect, no script, no handoff, no one else to lean on. When I got the sale wrong early on, it was never because I didn't know my own product well enough. It was because I was answering a question nobody was actually asking.
Fear, pride, and relief are the real drivers
Underneath almost every "yes" is one of a small set of motives: fear of losing ground to a competitor, pride in being seen as smart or capable, relief from a problem that has been dragging on too long, or the simple desire to stop doing something the hard way. Nobody says any of that out loud in a first call. They say things like "we're evaluating options" or "just doing some research."
Your job is not to accept that surface answer. It is to ask enough real questions, and then actually listen, until the real motive surfaces. Once you hear the emotional reason behind the request, the entire conversation gets easier, because now you are talking about what they actually care about instead of what you assume they care about.
How I try to get to the real reason
I ask about what happened right before they reached out. Not "what are you looking for," but "what changed." Something always changed: a bad quarter, a board member asking hard questions, a competitor moving faster, a person who used to handle this leaving. That trigger event usually points straight at the real motive.
I also pay attention to what they repeat. If someone brings up the same frustration twice in different words, that is not a coincidence. That is the thing driving the decision, and it deserves a direct follow-up question rather than a nod and a move to the next topic.
I learned this most clearly in nonprofit development. I once met with a donor I assumed would give again simply because he had given several times before. I had never really asked why. When I slowed down and listened, without a pitch in mind, I learned his giving was about honoring the memory of his father. From that moment, the conversation was less about the gift and more about how I could serve him. Sales works the same way. The presenting problem is rarely the real one.
The bottom line
You can know your product cold and still lose the sale if you never find out why the other person actually wants it. Discover their motive before you pitch your solution, and the rest of the conversation gets a lot shorter.
This is part 3 of our series on Jeffrey Gitomer's The Sales Bible. Previous: How to Build Rapport in Sales. Next: Sales Discovery Questions That Actually Work.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a need and a buying motive?
A need is the practical problem someone will tell you about. A buying motive is the emotional reason underneath it: fear, pride, relief, or ambition. The need explains what they want, the motive explains why they want it now.
How do I find out someone's real buying motive if they won't say it directly?
Ask what changed recently that made them start looking. People rarely volunteer the emotional reason, but they will usually tell you the trigger event, and the motive is almost always hiding inside that story.
Is it manipulative to sell to someone's emotional motives?
No, as long as what you are selling actually solves the problem. Understanding why someone wants something helps you have an honest conversation about whether you can actually help them, not push them toward something that won't.
James Martin
Growth consultant · 20+ years · $900MM in combined client revenue · 4 startup exits
Stay Updated
Get practical sales and marketing strategies delivered to your inbox.